Historic England’s Wolverton Works’ High Court challenge dismissed 

 

Knorr-Bremse 5th August announcement that they had sold the Wolverton rail renovation business  to what is described as a German based holding company called Mutares. KB purchased the rail business on 27 August 2013, four weeks after it had entered Administration and therefore ran Wolverton and Springburn for five years.

This sale which many locals consider not coincidental, closely followed the High Court’s dismissal on 30 July of the Appeal made on 23 May this year by Historic England against Planning Consent to demolish 99% of Wolverton Works. St Modwen then promptly sold Springburn on 6th August.

 

The High Court Ruling  was descibed as very disappointing by Historic England for two reasons:

1.Wolverton Works is the most complete example of a major UK Victorian railway Works

2.This Ruling means that in theory no Conservation Area is safe from demolition and redevelopment

The Judge, His Honour Mr Justice Dove said in his 44 page Ruling that he considered Milton Keynes Council was in law, entitled to come to the conclusion that the future use of one part of the site for railway-related employment and the replacement of the rest for housing outweighed the retention of the unlisted buildings for the contribution they make to the character of Wolverton.

 

The key to this decision is that property developers and Wolverton Works’ site owners St Modwen have said they will build a smaller railway works at the eastern end of the 38 acre site. Therefore rail-related employment will continue as the link to the past.

 

In theory any Conservation Area without listed buildings can now be demolished so long as any industry associated with it’s heritage continues in some form for historical continuity, even in modern buildings.

The World War 1 War Memorial to the 213 Wolverton men who died in that war has now been ready for erection since the start of last year and St Modwen refuse to answer questions about where it can be sited. Wolverton & Greenleys Council have tried to resolve this but only Knorr-Bremse who part funded the memorial, are assisting in this project.

 

Milton Keynes Council Leader Peter Marland has said that the buildings are in a dangerous state and Historic England should work with St Modwen to preserve what's left as much as possible.

He said; “Milton Keynes Council is responsible for making the decision on the Wolverton Works site, but we are not the land owner or applicant, and the Planning Committee needs to make decisions based on the law,"  

 

"The works are not just history, they still exist and we need to make sure they continue to exist into the future. Historic England have now failed in the High Court, they have failed with an application to the Secretary of State to “call in” the decision and they have failed to engage constructively at all with reality."

 

The new owners’ website states that Mutares “is a holding company that typically acquires companies or divisions that are no longer part of the core business of a larger corporation. As an investor with its own consulting team, Mutares specializes in increasing production efficiency, leveraging synergies and enabling growth. In particular, they invest in European companies that have significant potential for development and already possess established business models - often combined with strong brands

.

Behind this is the fear that as the kind of rail renovation work carried out at Wolverton comes to an end with the introduction of new train fleets in new rail franchises, bringing wholesale withdrawal of British Rail built trains, there will be no work beyond a few years time there.

 

The recent signing of a 25 year lease between St Modwen and Knorr-Bremse now seems to have been designed to offer continuity of rail-related work at Wolverton to satisfy planning constraints rather than the probability of such work continuing. The Chinese Railway and Rolling Stock Companies’ flirtation last year with Wolverton is also over so the Works’ future now looks to be bleak.

 

VOTE FOR WOLVERTON CONSERVATION AREA HERE